Chapter 5

The police dusted for fingerprints for three hours. They took the peanut, the rabbit, photos of the broken lock. They told us they’d increase patrols in the neighborhood, that they’d have a car drive by the house every hour through the night.
But I knew it wasn’t enough.
If Evelyn and Daniel wanted to get into the house, they would. They had money. They could hire people. They’d already proven they didn’t care about laws, or court orders, or basic human decency.
That afternoon, I made a decision.
We weren’t staying in Austin. Not anymore.
I called Mia and told her what had happened. She was quiet for a long time, then sighed.
“Okay. You’re right. They have people who can find you. Lila’s address is listed in the county property records. It took them five minutes to look it up. You need to go somewhere no one would think to look. Somewhere off the grid for a few days, until the hearing next week.”
“Where?” I said. “I don’t have any other family. All our friends are in Dallas. They know everyone we know.”
“Go to the cabin,” Mia said. “My grandma’s old cabin out in the Hill Country, outside Fredericksburg. It’s on twenty acres of land, surrounded by oak trees. No neighbors for a mile in any direction. The address isn’t listed anywhere online. It’s not in my name—it’s in a trust my grandma set up before she died. No one will find you there. I’ll text you the directions. I’ll have groceries delivered tomorrow morning. Just lay low. Don’t leave the property. Don’t answer the door for anyone. Call me if anything happens.”
An hour later, we were packed and in the car again. Sophie was confused, asking why we had to leave Aunt Lila’s house, why we were going to a cabin in the woods. I told her it was a special adventure, that we’d get to roast marshmallows and look for deer. She cheered up at that, talking nonstop about s’mores.
Lila followed us in her car for the first hour, then pulled off at an exit, blowing us a kiss and waving until we couldn’t see her anymore.
The drive to Fredericksburg took two and a half hours. The further we got from Austin, the narrower the roads got, the thicker the trees grew. Cell service got spotty, then disappeared completely. Mia’s directions led us down a long, rutted dirt road, surrounded on both sides by thick oak and cedar trees, the sun dappling through the leaves.
The cabin was small, made of rough-hewn cedar logs, with a big front porch and a stone chimney. It looked like something out of a storybook. A tall chain-link fence surrounded the whole property, the gate padlocked. Mia had texted me the combination that morning.
I unlocked the gate, drove through, and locked it again behind us.
Inside, the cabin was cozy. A big stone fireplace dominated the living room, with worn leather couches and a shelf full of old books. The kitchen was small but functional, with a wood stove and a gas fridge. There were two bedrooms, both with big, soft beds covered in handmade quilts.
We spent the rest of the afternoon exploring. We walked the perimeter of the property, Sophie running ahead of me, chasing butterflies and pointing out birds. We picked wildflowers from the meadow at the edge of the woods and put them in a mason jar on the kitchen table. That night, we made s’mores over the fire pit in the backyard, Sophie laughing when she got marshmallow all over her face.
For the first time in days, I let my guard down a little. The gate was locked. No one knew we were here. We were surrounded by trees, by silence, by nothing but nature. We were safe.
Or so I thought.
The next morning, I woke up early. Sophie was still asleep, curled up under the quilt, her thumb in her mouth. I put on my shoes and walked outside to get some fresh air, carrying a mug of coffee. I leaned against the porch rail, breathing in the smell of pine and wood smoke, watching the sun come up over the hills.
That was when I saw it.
A black SUV was parked at the end of the dirt road, half-hidden behind a big oak tree. It was too far away to see the license plate, but I’d know that car anywhere. It was the same one Evelyn drove. The same one I’d seen parked in her driveway a hundred times.
My blood turned to ice.
I stood frozen, my coffee mug slipping in my hand, spilling hot coffee down my shirt. I didn’t feel it.
The SUV started. It turned around slowly, driving back the way it had come, disappearing around a bend in the road.
They’d found us.
I ran inside, slamming the front door and locking all three deadbolts. I pushed the heavy wooden coffee table in front of the door. I ran to the bedroom, shaking Sophie awake.
“Mommy? What’s wrong?” she mumbled, rubbing her eyes.
“Get dressed, baby. Fast. We have to go.”
I threw our things back into the suitcases, my hands shaking so bad I could barely zip them. I grabbed my phone, running to the kitchen to call Mia. There was still no cell service. I’d have to drive ten minutes back toward town to get a signal.
I strapped Sophie into her car seat, threw the suitcases in the trunk, and ran back to the gate to unlock it. My hands were shaking so bad I dropped the padlock twice.
I peeled out of the driveway, heading back toward town as fast as the dirt road would let me. I kept checking the rearview mirror, half-expecting the black SUV to come barreling up behind us.
Five minutes later, my phone finally got a bar of service. It started blowing up with missed calls and text messages. Most were from Mia and Lila. But one was from an unknown number, sent ten minutes before.
I opened it.
It was a photo.
A photo of me, standing on the front porch of the cabin that morning, holding my coffee mug. I was looking right at the camera, completely unaware.
The text below the photo said:
Nice cabin. Too bad it’s so isolated. No one would hear you scream out here.
I gasped, almost driving off the road. I swerved, correcting the wheel at the last second, my heart hammering so hard I could hear it in my ears.
They’d been there. They’d been watching me sleep. They’d been ten yards from the cabin while my daughter was in her bed, completely defenseless.
I called Mia, screaming into the phone when she picked up.
“They found us! They were at the cabin! They took a photo of me on the porch! Mia, they’re everywhere! There’s nowhere we can go!”
Mia’s voice was sharp, urgent, cutting through my panic.
“Listen to me! Drive straight to the Fredericksburg police station. It’s on Main Street, right in the middle of town. Do not stop for anything. Do not answer your phone for anyone except me or Lila. I’m calling the Gillespie County sheriff right now, I’m telling them everything. I’m leaving Dallas in twenty minutes, I’ll be there in three hours. Just get to the police station. Stay there until I arrive. Do you understand me?”
“Yes.”
“Good. Now drive. And Sarah? Whatever you do—don’t look back.”
I hung up and pressed my foot harder on the gas. The car bounced over the ruts in the road, rocks flying up under the tires. Sophie was crying in the backseat, scared by my panic, asking what was wrong. I didn’t answer her. I couldn’t. All I could think about was the photo. About how close they’d been. About how easily they could have walked through that unlocked cabin door in the middle of the night and taken Sophie while I slept.
I pulled into the police station parking lot ten minutes later. I ran inside, carrying Sophie, screaming for help. Two officers jumped up from their desks, rushing over to me. I told them everything, showed them the text message, the photo. They took me into an interview room, gave Sophie a stuffed bear and a juice box, and started taking my statement.
Three hours later, Mia walked in. She looked tired, her suit wrinkled from the drive, but her eyes were fierce. She hugged me hard, then sat down across from me, spreading papers out on the table.
“Okay. The game has changed. They’ve crossed a line. Breaking and entering, stalking, harassment, threatening texts—this isn’t just a custody fight anymore. This is criminal. I just got off the phone with the district attorney in Dallas. They’re going to issue arrest warrants for Daniel and Evelyn for stalking and violation of the restraining orders. We’re also going to ask the judge to revoke Daniel’s bail and remand him into custody until the trial. He’s not going to be able to follow you around anymore once he’s in a jail cell.”
She paused, leaning forward, her voice softer.
“I also got a call this morning from Daniel’s younger brother, Jake. You remember him? The one who moved to California a few years ago, the one Evelyn never talks about?”
I nodded. Jake was three years younger than Daniel. He’d been the black sheep of the family, the one who’d refused to go to the fancy college Evelyn had picked out, the one who’d started his own construction company instead of joining the family real estate business. I’d only met him twice, at the wedding and at Sophie’s first birthday. He’d been nice, quiet, nothing like the rest of them.
“What about him?” I said.
“He saw the security video. Someone in the family sent it to him. He’s horrified. He says he’s known for years that Evelyn is manipulative and controlling, that she bullies everyone into doing what she wants. He says he has proof. Bank records. Texts. Emails. Everything about the payments to Dr. Henderson, about the plan to take Sophie to Mexico, about all of it. He’s flying to Austin tonight. He’s willing to testify against them. For you.”
I stared at her. A member of the family, willing to turn on his own mother and brother?
“Why?” I said. “Why would he help me?”
Mia’s face was serious.
“Because he has a little girl too. She’s five. He says he would burn the whole world down before he let anyone hurt her. He says Evelyn has destroyed enough lives. It’s time someone stopped her.”
A knock on the interview room door. One of the officers stuck his head in.
“Mrs. Carter-Wilson? There’s a man here to see you. Says his name is Jake Wilson. Says he’s your brother-in-law. He has a lawyer with him. Says he has information about your case.”
I looked at Mia. She nodded.
“Let him in.”
The door opened. Jake walked in. He was tall, with the same dark hair and blue eyes as Daniel, but that was where the resemblance ended. He had a scar across his left cheek, calloused hands, and tattoos peeking out from the sleeves of his flannel shirt. He looked nervous, his hands stuffed in his jeans pockets.
Behind him was a woman in a gray suit, carrying a briefcase.
Jake stopped when he saw me. He held up his hands, like he was trying to show me he wasn’t a threat.
“Sarah. I know you have no reason to trust me. And I don’t blame you. My family has done unforgivable things to you and Sophie. But I’m here to help. Whatever you need. Whatever it takes. I’m not going to let them hurt that little girl.”
He reached into his bag and pulled out a thick stack of papers, slamming them down on the table.
“These are all the records. Every payment my mom made to Dr. Henderson. Every text between her and Daniel about the plan. Every email. I’ve had them for a week. I was going to turn them over to the police, but then I heard you’d gone into hiding. I had to find you. I had to make sure you were okay.”
I looked at the papers. Bank statements. Text transcripts. Emails. All dated, all signed. All the proof we needed to put Evelyn and Daniel away for a long time.
I looked up at Jake. He was staring at Sophie, who was sitting on the couch in the corner coloring, a small, sad smile on his face.
“Why?” I said again, my voice quiet. “Why are you doing this?”
Jake looked at me. His eyes were full of pain.
“Because my mom did the same thing to my daughter last year,” he said. “Lily has a dairy allergy. Severe. Mom thought it was ‘all in her head.’ She gave her a glass of milk when my wife wasn’t looking. Lily ended up in the ER for three days. I never told anyone. I was ashamed. I thought if I just stayed away, she’d leave us alone. But then I saw the video of Sophie. I realized she’ll never stop. She’ll keep hurting kids until someone stops her. And I’m not going to let her hurt anyone else’s baby ever again.”
He held out his hand.
“I’m on your side, Sarah. For as long as it takes. What do you say?”
I looked at his hand. At the stack of papers on the table. At Sophie, laughing as she colored a picture of a unicorn.
May you like
I took his hand and shook it.
“Okay,” I said. “Let’s take them down.”