Chapter 4

The police came to Mia’s office an hour later. Two uniformed officers, plus a detective from the family crimes unit. They took my statement, photographed the texts on Daniel’s iPad, and told me they’d open a formal investigation.
By that afternoon, Daniel had been served with his own restraining order. He was prohibited from contacting me, contacting Sophie, coming within five hundred feet of us, or going anywhere near our house, Sophie’s school, or Mia’s office. The police went to our house to make sure he’d left. He was gone, but his car was still in the driveway.
Mia told me to get out of Dallas as fast as I could.
“Go to your sister’s in Austin,” she said, handing me a stack of court papers. “Lay low. Don’t post anything on social media. Don’t tell anyone except me and Lila where you are. Daniel and Evelyn are desperate now. They know those texts could put them in jail. There’s no telling what they’ll do next.”
I left Mia’s office at five, just as the sun was starting to set over the Dallas skyline. I strapped Sophie into her car seat, handed her a juice box and her tablet, and pulled onto the highway heading south. The three-hour drive to Austin stretched out in front of me. I kept checking the rearview mirror every two minutes, half-convinced Daniel or Evelyn would be following me in their black SUV.
An hour outside of Waco, my phone rang. It was Lila, my younger sister, a pediatric nurse who’d moved to Austin two years before. I’d called her that morning, told her everything, and she’d already cleaned out the guest room and bought all of Sophie’s favorite snacks.
“Are you almost here?” she said, her voice full of worry. “I’ve got the porch light on. I made mac and cheese for Sophie. Extra cheese, like she likes it.”
“Another hour and a half,” I said. “Traffic’s light. We’re making good time.”
“Good. Hey… Sarah? The police called me. They said to make sure all the doors and windows are locked, to keep the security system on. I already did it. And I bought that big baseball bat from the garage, put it next to my bed. No one’s getting in here to hurt either of you, okay? I promise.”
Tears stung my eyes. Lila was two years younger than me, but she’d always been the brave one, the one who stood up to bullies in middle school, the one who held my hand when our mom died.
“Thanks, Lila. I don’t know what I’d do without you.”
“Hey, that’s what sisters are for. Now drive safe. I’ll see you soon.”
I hung up and looked in the backseat. Sophie had fallen asleep, her head lolled to the side, her juice box still in her hand. I reached back and tucked a strand of hair behind her ear, my fingers brushing her soft cheek.
We pulled into Lila’s neighborhood at eight-thirty. It was a quiet, tree-lined subdivision in Round Rock, north of Austin, with big brick houses and well-manicured lawns. Lila was standing on the front porch when I drove up, her arms crossed, watching for us. She ran down the steps as soon as I parked, yanking open the back door to hug Sophie.
“Hey, peanut! Oh, I missed you so much! Look how big you’ve gotten!”
Sophie woke up, rubbing her eyes, and grinned when she saw her aunt. She threw her arms around Lila’s neck, chattering about the cartoons she’d watched on the drive. Lila unbuckled her, carried her up the steps, and walked her inside, leaving me to haul the suitcases from the trunk.
I stood there for a minute in the dark driveway, breathing in the smell of cut grass and jasmine from the bushes next to the porch. For the first time all week, I felt like I could breathe.
I grabbed the last suitcase and walked inside. Lila had made the house feel like home. She’d lit vanilla candles, put on Sophie’s favorite movie in the living room, and set the dining room table with three plates piled high with mac and cheese, chicken nuggets, and steamed broccoli.
We ate dinner together, Sophie telling Lila every detail of her new favorite cartoon, laughing so hard she snort-laughed at one point. It was the first time I’d heard her laugh like that since the birthday dinner. My chest ached, both happy and sad, knowing this was the first normal night she’d had in weeks.
After dinner, Lila gave Sophie a bath and tucked her into the guest room bed, reading her three stories before she fell asleep. She came back to the living room, where I was sitting on the couch staring at the wall, and sat down next to me, handing me a glass of wine.
“Drink this. You look like you need it.”
I took a big sip. The cold, crisp white wine burned going down, but it felt good.
“Thanks.”
We sat in silence for a long time, listening to the crickets chirp outside. Then Lila put her hand on my arm.
“Tell me the truth. How bad is this? Are they really going to try to take her?”
I looked at her. The texts from Daniel’s iPad were burned into my brain.
“They’re rich, Lila. They have connections. Evelyn has a doctor in her pocket who was willing to lie and say I’m crazy. They already tried to kill her once, and they almost got away with it. Yeah. They’re going to try. They’re never going to stop.”
Lila’s jaw tightened. She nodded, her eyes hard.
“Then we’ll be ready. I put a security camera by the front door and one over the back fence. The alarm system is on every window and door. I talked to my neighbor, Bob—he’s a retired cop. He said he’ll keep an eye on the house, call me if he sees anything strange. And I work at the hospital, remember? I know every pediatrician, every social worker, every cop in this county. They’re not getting within a mile of Sophie without going through me first.”
I hugged her, crying into her shoulder. She held me tight, rubbing my back, whispering that it was going to be okay.
I fell asleep on the couch that night, the baseball bat Lila had talked about resting on the coffee table within arm’s reach. I didn’t sleep well. Every little creak of the house, every car that drove down the street, made me jump, my hand flying to the bat.
I woke up at seven the next morning to the smell of pancakes and bacon. Sophie was sitting at the kitchen table, covered in syrup, drawing a picture of a rainbow. Lila was flipping pancakes at the stove, singing off-key to a Taylor Swift song.
For a second, I let myself believe it was all going to be okay. That Daniel and Evelyn would give up, that we could build a new life here in Austin, that Sophie would grow up happy and safe and never have to think about them again.
Then my phone rang.
It was the alarm company.
“Mrs. Carter-Wilson? This is ADT Security. We’re showing a breach at the back door of your sister’s residence at 4:17 this morning. The alarm was triggered, but it was reset with the master code ten seconds later. Did you or your sister authorize anyone to enter the house last night?”
My blood ran cold. I looked at Lila. She was staring at me, her spatula frozen in mid-air, the pancake in the pan starting to burn.
“No,” I said, my voice shaking. “No one was supposed to be here. No one has the code except me and my sister.”
“Okay. We’re dispatching the local police to the residence right now. They should be there in three to five minutes. I’d advise you and your family to stay inside, lock all interior doors, and wait for them to arrive. Do not open the door for anyone until you see a uniformed officer and verify their badge number.”
The line went dead.
Lila turned off the stove. She walked to the kitchen drawer, pulled out a big chef’s knife, and held it in her hand. Her face was pale, but her voice was steady.
“Go get Sophie. Lock yourselves in the master bedroom. Call 911, tell them to hurry. I’ll check the back of the house.”
“Lila, no—”
“Go! Now!”
I ran down the hall to the guest room. Sophie was still sitting at the table, her crayon frozen in mid-air, her big eyes wide with fear. I grabbed her, lifting her into my arms, and ran to the master bedroom, slamming the door shut and locking it. I pushed the heavy dresser in front of the door, then sat on the bed with Sophie huddled in my lap, my hand over her mouth to muffle her whimpers.
I could hear Lila walking through the house, her footsteps slow, deliberate. I heard the back door open. Then I heard her yell.
“Oh my God. Oh my God.”
A minute later, there was a soft knock on the bedroom door.
“Sarah? It’s me. It’s okay. The police are here. You can come out.”
I moved the dresser and unlocked the door. Lila was standing in the hallway, the knife still in her hand, her face as white as a sheet. Two uniformed officers were behind her, their hands on their guns.
I walked past them to the back door. It was standing wide open. The lock on the doorknob was broken, the metal bent like someone had pried it open with a crowbar.
On the kitchen table, right next to Sophie’s half-finished rainbow drawing, was Sophie’s favorite stuffed rabbit. The one she’d slept with every night since she was two. The one I’d packed in her suitcase, the one I’d seen her tuck under her arm when we walked into the house the night before.
And next to the rabbit, sitting on the white tablecloth, was a single, whole peanut in its shell.
One of the officers knelt down, putting on gloves to pick it up. He looked up at me, his face serious.
“Someone was in here, ma’am. They didn’t steal anything. They just left this. It’s a warning.”
I stared at the peanut. At the rabbit. I thought of Evelyn’s voice in my ear, whispering that the family would destroy me. I thought of Daniel’s texts, talking about taking Sophie to Mexico.
They knew where we were. They’d been in the house. They’d stood over my daughter while she slept, and left a message telling me they could get to her any time they wanted.
I looked at Lila. She was holding Sophie now, rocking her back and forth, whispering that everything was okay. But her eyes were scared.
May you like
They’d found us in less than twenty-four hours.
And they weren’t going to stop.