season

Chapter 3 - The Woman Who Helped Decorate My Nursery Had Been Keeping a Second Set of Keys

Chelsea didn't answer my next message. Instead, she sent a photograph.

It showed our kitchen table. On it lay the little yellow envelope where Trent and I kept receipts for the nursery, alongside a sheet of paper covered in numbers. I recognized the handwriting. It was mine.

Except I had never written those numbers.

At the top someone had printed: PRIVATE PATERNITY CONSULTATION.

I stared until the words blurred.

Mallory read over my shoulder. "That's not yours."

"I know."

The paper listed dates, estimated conception windows, and the name Ethan Ross. It was designed to look like evidence that I had questioned the paternity of my own children.

I called Chelsea. She answered on the fourth ring.

"Why do you have that?" I asked.

"Because I made it."

My stomach turned.

"You made a fake document?"

"I was trying to make Trent tell you what he was feeling. He kept saying he was scared the babies weren't his. I thought if he saw something that looked real, he'd finally ask you instead of swallowing it."

"That doesn't make sense."

"I know."

"Did you show it to him?"

She didn't answer.

"Chelsea."

"Yes."

I pressed my palm against my incision, as though I could hold my body together by force. "When?"

"Three weeks ago."

For three weeks my husband had been living with a forged document suggesting I had betrayed him. For three weeks he'd asked questions about my appointments, watched Ethan's face, and withdrawn from me in increments so small I had blamed pregnancy fatigue.

"Why didn't he tell me?"

"I told him I found it while helping organize the nursery. I said I didn't know what it meant."

"You told him you found something you created."

"Yes."

The simplicity of the answer was almost worse than a defense.

"Why?"

Her breathing became uneven. "Because I was angry."

"At me?"

"You had everything. The house, the marriage, the babies. I kept telling myself I was happy for you. And then Trent started talking to me about how lonely he felt, and I liked being the person he called."

There it was. Not a grand conspiracy, not a villain's speech. A friend admitting she had enjoyed becoming necessary to my husband.

"Were you having an affair?"

"Not the way you're thinking."

"Then tell me the way I should think."

She said they had exchanged late-night messages for months. He complained that I was distant. She reassured him that he deserved to be heard. He bought her coffee when he was working near her office. Twice they met for dinner and told me they were with coworkers. She said they had kissed once in his truck, then agreed it could never happen again.

I felt something inside me go very still.

"When?"

"February."

February was when I had been admitted overnight for monitoring. Trent told me he'd gone home to collect clean clothes. Chelsea had offered to feed our cat.

"You kissed my husband while I was in the hospital?"

"Natalie, I'm sorry."

"Do not use my name like we're having one of our old conversations."

I ended the call.

Mallory sat beside me, waiting. I couldn't speak. The nurse came in to check my blood pressure, noticed my expression, and asked whether I needed a moment. I said yes. It was the first time in two days that I had asked for something without explaining why.

That evening I called Trent. He answered immediately.

"Did you kiss Chelsea in February?"

The silence lasted long enough to answer.

"Natalie—"

"Yes or no."

"Yes."

I looked at the notebook. Leo had gained a little weight. Cora was still receiving respiratory support. Mae had been restless after a feeding. These were the facts that mattered now, yet my husband's confession seemed determined to occupy every inch of the room.

"Did you see a document about paternity?"

"She showed me something."

"She forged it."

"She told me today."

"You knew she was lying and still accused me in front of the staff?"

"I didn't know then."

"You knew you had kissed her. You knew you'd kept it from me. You knew you were accusing me of the very betrayal you had committed."

His voice dropped. "You're right."

"I don't need you to agree with me to make this conversation end."

I hung up before he could say anything else.

The next morning, Lorraine returned. She asked permission to sit and listened while I told her about the kiss. She didn't defend him. When I finished, she folded her hands around a paper cup of coffee.

"His father had a talent for making his guilt sound like someone else's responsibility," she said. "I hoped Trent had learned a different lesson."

"Did you know about Chelsea?"

"No. And if I had, you would have heard it from me."

I believed her. That belief hurt, too. It reminded me that people could choose honesty even when it cost them.

Later, I spoke with a social worker about practical support after discharge. Three premature babies would mean appointments, feeding plans, sleepless nights, and medical bills. I had expected to face those challenges with a husband. I now needed a plan that didn't depend on whether he was sorry enough.

Mallory offered her spare room. It wasn't big enough for three cribs, but it was big enough for me to recover while the babies remained hospitalized. Lorraine offered to help with meals and transportation, subject to my boundaries. A coworker offered to organize leave paperwork.

I began to understand that losing the marriage I thought I had did not mean losing every form of family.

On the fourth day after delivery, I went to see Cora. The respiratory therapist explained a change in her support and answered my questions without rushing. I held my daughter's foot through the opening of the incubator.

"You're allowed to take your time," I whispered. "All of us are."

Back in my room, I found a voicemail from an attorney Chelsea had apparently consulted. The message was brief. Chelsea wanted to return a house key and provide copies of the messages she'd exchanged with Trent. The attorney suggested arranging the transfer through a neutral third party.

I forwarded the voicemail to Mallory. "Can you handle this?"

"Absolutely."

"And change the locks?"

"Already called someone."

I almost smiled.

Then Mallory said, "There's one more thing. Chelsea sent the messages. Trent wasn't the only person she was talking to."

On the screen was a conversation with a number saved as Tasha H.

The nurse who had joked about my college boyfriend.

Chelsea had written: He needs to hear it from someone inside the hospital. Otherwise he won't believe me.

Tasha had replied: I can make sure he hears enough.

I looked up at my sister.

May you like

"This wasn't just jealousy," I said.

"No," Mallory answered. "It was a plan."

Related Stories

Other posts