Chapter 6 - Three weeks after Cassidy asked for Dominic’s mother’s ring, she discovered marriage was much easier when nobody was trying to buy it, investigate it, expose it, prosecute it or use it as evidence.
It was also louder.
Mostly because of Pancake.
At six-fifteen on a Wednesday morning, the dog crashed into the bedroom door carrying one of Dominic’s socks in his mouth.
Dominic opened one eye.
“Why is he in here?”
Cassidy remained facedown against the pillow.
“Because you taught him how to open lever handles.”
“I did not teach him.”
“You demonstrated.”
“I opened a door.”
“In front of him.”
“He’s a dog.”
“He’s a criminal.”
Pancake jumped onto the bed.
Dominic sat up as seventy pounds of badly coordinated enthusiasm landed directly on his stomach.
He made a sound Cassidy had never heard from another human being.
She began laughing.
“This animal is trying to kill me.”
“You survived federal prison.”
“Federal prison had rules.”
Pancake dropped the sock on Dominic’s chest.
Cassidy turned onto her side.
Morning light came through the curtains.
Dominic’s hair stuck up strangely on one side.
His mother’s ring rested on Cassidy’s left hand.
For a moment, nothing hurt.
That still surprised her.
Not happiness.
She had learned happiness could exist beside pain.
What surprised her was ordinariness.
There had been a time when every day with Dominic seemed attached to something enormous.
Money.
Custody.
Crime.
Fear.
Courtrooms.
Separation.
Now the biggest problem in the room was whether Dominic could retrieve his sock without encouraging Pancake to turn theft into a morning tradition.
“Don’t chase him,” Cassidy said.
Dominic was already standing.
“I need the sock.”
“You have more socks.”
“That is not the principle.”
Pancake ran.
Dominic followed.
Cassidy heard Emily shout from the hallway.
“HE STOLE YOUR OTHER ONE TOO!”
Dominic stopped.
“Why do you know that?”
“Because I helped him.”
Cassidy closed her eyes and smiled into the pillow.
This was the boring life Dominic had requested.
Apparently, nobody had explained that boring did not mean peaceful.
By eight-thirty, Cassidy was at Miller Table, the first restaurant she had purchased after the investigation.
There were now three.
The second was a breakfast place in Wilmette.
The third, purchased only six months earlier, occupied the ground floor of an old brick building near the lake and had required more money, more contractors and more arguments about plumbing than Cassidy had believed legally possible.
She loved all three.
Not sentimentally.
Restaurants were too exhausting for sentimentality before noon.
She loved their movement.
Invoices arrived.
Employees called in sick.
Deliveries came late.
Dishwashers broke.
Customers complained that tables near windows had too much sunlight while other customers complained that tables away from windows had too little.
Problems could be solved.
Cassidy had developed a profound affection for solvable problems.
At ten-forty, Rebecca Sloan walked into her office holding a thick envelope.
Cassidy looked at it.
“No.”
Rebecca sat across from her.
“I haven’t said anything.”
“You’re carrying lawyer paper.”
“All paper is lawyer paper if a lawyer carries it.”
“That is exactly the kind of thing lawyers say.”
Rebecca placed the envelope on the desk.
Cassidy did not touch it.
“Dominic knows?”
“Not yet.”
That changed everything.
Cassidy straightened.
“What is it?”
“Civil litigation.”
Her stomach tightened automatically.
Rebecca noticed.
“Not against you.”
“Against Dominic?”
“Not exactly.”
“Rebecca.”
“Several former Vale Meridian employees and pension beneficiaries have reopened claims involving transactions from twenty to twenty-five years ago.”
Cassidy leaned back.
That period predated Dominic’s control of the company.
Mostly.
“What does that have to do with him?”
“His father.”
Cassidy was silent.
Dominic rarely spoke about his father.
When he did, his sentences became short enough to cut things.
Rebecca continued.
“The plaintiffs believe money was diverted from an employee pension program into holding companies controlled by senior Vale family members.”
“Dominic already turned over everything he had.”
“Everything he knew he had.”
Cassidy looked at the envelope.
“And now?”
“An attorney representing the plaintiffs found a reference to a private archive maintained by Dominic’s mother.”
Cassidy’s eyes lifted.
“His mother?”
“Eleanor Vale.”
Cassidy knew the name.
She had seen it on the back of old photographs.
On one scholarship fund Dominic quietly restored after his release.
On the brass plate beneath a painting he kept in his apartment but never hung in their house because, he once explained, his mother would have hated the frame.
“What archive?”
“We don’t know.”
“Then why come to me?”
“Because someone believes Dominic does.”
Cassidy shook her head.
“He doesn’t.”
“You’re sure?”
“Yes.”
Rebecca studied her.
Cassidy frowned.
“What?”
“You answered quickly.”
“Because I know my husband.”
“That sentence used to make you angry.”
“Most things used to make me angry.”
“Most things still make you angry.”
“True.”
Rebecca opened the envelope and removed a photocopy.
It showed an inventory from an old Vale family property near Lake Geneva.
Furniture.
Paintings.
Documents.
Personal effects.
One line had been circled.
E. Vale — private records — blue room storage.
Cassidy read it twice.
“When was this made?”
“Six months after her death.”
“And where are the records?”
“Nobody knows.”
“Who owns the property?”
“Vale Heritage Trust.”
Cassidy laughed without humor.
“Of course there’s a trust.”
“There is always a trust.”
“Who controls it?”
Rebecca hesitated.
That was enough.
“Someone Dominic hates?”
“Charles Vale.”
Cassidy knew that name too.
Dominic’s uncle.
His father’s younger brother.
Former Vale Meridian board member.
Not charged during the federal investigation because prosecutors had been unable to connect him directly to the transactions Dominic disclosed.
Dominic had described him once.
Not cruel.
Worse.
Careful.
“Does Charles know people are looking for the archive?”
“Almost certainly.”
Cassidy stood.
“Then why hasn’t Dominic been contacted?”
“He has.”
Cassidy went still.
Rebecca reached into the envelope.
She removed another document.
A copy of a letter.
Delivered two days earlier to Dominic’s attorney.
Cassidy read the first line.
Mr. Vale, your voluntary cooperation is requested—
Her anger arrived quietly.
That was usually the dangerous kind.
“He didn’t tell me.”
“Maybe he intended to.”
“Rebecca.”
“I am not defending him.”
“Good.”
“I am saying three weeks is not historically a long time for Dominic Vale to consider whether information qualifies as terrifying enough to conceal.”
Cassidy looked at her.
“That is defending him with better vocabulary.”
Rebecca smiled faintly.
Cassidy picked up her phone.
She stopped before calling.
Once, she would have demanded an explanation immediately.
Once, Dominic would have heard anger and prepared defense.
They had done that dance enough times to learn where it ended.
She put the phone down.
“What exactly do the plaintiffs want?”
“Access to the property. Dominic’s cooperation identifying anything that belonged to his mother. Potential testimony if documents are recovered.”
“And Charles?”
“His attorney says no archive exists.”
“Convenient.”
“Very.”
The office door opened.
Emily walked in carrying a poster board nearly as large as she was.
She was ten now.
Tall enough that the pantry height mark required an annual update.
Old enough to understand when adults stopped talking because she entered.
Young enough to hate it.
She looked between Cassidy and Rebecca.
“Why are you doing the secret face?”
“What secret face?” Cassidy asked.
“The one where your eyebrows get mean.”
“My eyebrows don’t get mean.”
Rebecca said, “They do.”
“Betrayal.”
Emily placed the poster board on the desk.
It read:
FAMILY HISTORY PROJECT.
Cassidy stared at it.
Rebecca began laughing.
“What?”
Cassidy pointed.
“Timing.”
Emily frowned.
“We have to make a family tree.”
“Of course you do.”
“And interview relatives.”
“Of course.”
“And bring one family object with a story.”
Cassidy looked at Rebecca.
Rebecca stood.
“I should leave.”
“You absolutely should not.”
“I bill hourly.”
“Coward.”
Emily watched them.
“What happened?”
Cassidy sighed.
“Nothing you need to worry about.”
“That means something happened.”
“It means adult paperwork.”
Emily accepted that more easily.
Adult paperwork had become a category in their house roughly equivalent to weather: occasionally inconvenient, rarely exciting and usually accompanied by Dominic swearing under his breath.
“Can Dominic help?” Emily asked.
“With what?”
“The family tree.”
Cassidy looked toward the envelope.
“Yes.”
Emily smiled.
“He knows dead people.”
Rebecca coughed.
Cassidy covered her face.
“That is not how we describe genealogy.”
“Same thing.”
That evening Dominic came home at seven-twelve.
He had started working as an operations consultant for a regional logistics firm rather than accepting the Milwaukee position.
The pay was far below what he had once earned.
He loved the work more.
Cassidy suspected this offended him philosophically.
He entered the kitchen carrying milk.
He placed it dramatically on the counter.
Cassidy stared.
“What?”
“I remembered.”
“There was no grocery list.”
“I bought it preemptively.”
“Growth.”
Emily entered behind him.
“Did you buy cheese?”
Dominic’s face hardened.
“This family refuses to let history die.”
Cassidy looked at him.
History.
The word changed something in her expression.
Dominic saw it.
He always did.
Emily spread her family-tree assignment across the table.
“I need dead relatives.”
Dominic removed his coat.
“I have many.”
“Perfect.”
Cassidy said nothing.
Dominic looked at her again.
“What happened?”
“Dinner first.”
“Cassidy.”
“Dinner.”
Emily glanced between them.
“Secret face.”
Dominic sighed.
“What secret face?”
“Her eyebrows.”
Cassidy pointed at her sister.
“Homework.”
Emily took her papers to the living room.
Dominic waited until she disappeared.
Then he looked at Cassidy.
“You spoke to Rebecca.”
It was not a question.
Cassidy leaned against the counter.
“You knew.”
“Yes.”
“For two days.”
“Yes.”
“And you did not tell me.”
“No.”
She nodded slowly.
Dominic braced himself.
She could see it.
The old instinct.
Prepare for impact.
“I’m not going to yell.”
“That is somehow worse.”
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
He removed his watch.
The anxious habit remained.
He loosened the strap, tightened it, then finally placed it on the counter.
“Because I didn’t know if it was real.”
“The request?”
“The archive.”
“You knew the request was real.”
“Yes.”
“Then you could have told me there was a request.”
“I could have.”
“But?”
Dominic looked toward the living room.
Emily was humming while drawing branches.
“My mother spent years trying to leave my father. Every time she almost did, someone convinced her she had nowhere safe to go.”
Cassidy’s anger faded slightly.
Not disappeared.
Shifted.
“What does that have to do with the archive?”
“I don’t know what she kept.”
“Then say that.”
“I don’t know what she kept.”
“Good.”
He almost smiled.
She did not.
Dominic looked down.
“When she died, I was twenty. My father controlled everything. Her clothes disappeared from the house within a week. Her office was emptied. Family photographs were boxed. I never asked where things went.”
“Why?”
“Because I was surviving him.”
There it was.
Not an excuse.
A fact.
Cassidy crossed her arms.
“And now you’re afraid of what she might have left.”
“Yes.”
“Because it could implicate her?”
“No.”
His answer came immediately.
Cassidy waited.
Dominic’s voice lowered.
“Because it might prove she asked me for help.”
Cassidy stopped breathing for a second.
He continued.
“The week before she died, she came to my apartment. She asked whether I would leave Chicago with her.”
Cassidy had never heard this.
“What did you say?”
“I told her I had exams.”
She closed her eyes.
“Dominic.”
“I was twenty.”
“I know.”
“I told her we could talk after the semester.”
“You didn’t know.”
“No.”
His jaw tightened.
“But I remember looking at her and knowing she was frightened.”
Cassidy moved closer.
He did not look at her.
“I knew,” he repeated.
“You knew she was frightened. You did not know she was going to die.”
“That distinction has never felt useful.”
Cassidy touched his hand.
He let her.
“If there are records,” she said, “we find them.”
Dominic looked at her.
“Why?”
“Because hiding from dead people has not worked particularly well for this family.”
A breath of laughter escaped him.
Then he became serious.
“Charles will fight access.”
“Then let him.”
“He may attack me publicly again.”
“People already know you committed felonies.”
“Yes.”
“Your reputation is not exactly made of glass.”
“That is not what worries me.”
“I know.”
He looked toward Emily.
Cassidy squeezed his hand.
“You do not get to protect me by deciding what I’m allowed to know.”
“I know.”
“And you don’t get to protect Emily that way either.”
“I know.”
“Good.”
“Are you finished?”
“No.”
“I assumed.”
“If you ever hide a legal request from me again, I will make Pancake sleep on your side of the bed permanently.”
Dominic looked genuinely alarmed.
“That is disproportionate.”
“Learn from it.”
Emily returned carrying a marker.
“Are you fighting?”
Cassidy said, “A little.”
Dominic said, “Your sister threatened me.”
Emily looked interested.
“With what?”
“Pancake.”
Emily considered.
“That’s fair.”
Dominic stared at both of them.
“I regret marrying into this family.”
Cassidy raised her left hand.
His mother’s ring caught the kitchen light.
“You had two opportunities to avoid it.”
His eyes went to the ring.
Then to her face.
“No,” he said quietly. “I didn’t.”
The following morning, Dominic authorized Rebecca and the plaintiffs’ attorneys to petition for access to the Lake Geneva property.
Charles Vale responded within four hours.
Not through lawyers.
Directly.
Dominic’s phone rang while he sat in Cassidy’s restaurant office reviewing supplier invoices.
He looked at the screen.
Cassidy saw the name.
CHARLES VALE.
Dominic almost declined.
Cassidy said, “Answer.”
He put the phone on speaker.
His uncle’s voice arrived smooth and controlled.
“Dominic.”
“Charles.”
“You’re making a mistake.”
“I’ve made several. Be specific.”
Cassidy nearly smiled.
Charles continued.
“Your mother kept private things private for a reason.”
Dominic’s face changed.
Cassidy watched every trace of humor leave it.
“What reason?”
“She understood what public scandal did to families.”
“No,” Dominic said. “She understood what families did to people who told the truth.”
Silence.
Then Charles laughed softly.
“You sound like her.”
Dominic’s fingers tightened around the phone.
“What is in the blue room?”
Another pause.
And Cassidy knew.
Charles knew exactly what was there.
His answer confirmed it.
“Nothing that will make you feel better.”
Dominic looked at Cassidy.
She held his gaze.
He said, “That wasn’t the question.”
“No,” Charles replied. “But it is the answer.”
The call ended.
For several seconds, neither of them spoke.
Then Cassidy reached for her coat.
Dominic frowned.
“Where are you going?”
“To work.”
“You are at work.”
“My other work.”
“What other work?”
“Making sure Rebecca gets that call documented.”
Dominic stood.
“Cassidy.”
She stopped.
“What?”
His expression was strange.
Almost frightened.
Almost grateful.
“You don’t have to do this with me.”
She looked at him for a long moment.
Then she walked back.
She placed both hands on his face.
“I know.”
That was the difference.
She kissed his forehead.
The same place he had kissed her during the first ceremony.
Then she stepped away.
May you like
“I’m doing it anyway.”
And for once, Dominic did not argue.
Related Stories
